Midas MR18 vs Behringer XR18: A Detailed Comparison

When it comes to mixing audio for live performances or studio recordings, having the right equipment is crucial. The Midas MR18 and Behringer XR18 are both highly regarded digital mixers that offer professional sound quality, advanced features, and the flexibility of tablet-based control. Both mixers are equipped with 18 inputs and Midas-designed preamps, making them suitable for a variety of applications, from live concerts to studio sessions. However, they come with distinct differences that can influence which one is the best fit for your needs. In this report, we’ll dive deep into a comparison of the Midas MR18 and Behringer XR18, evaluating their key features, sound quality, connectivity, and value for money to help you make an informed decision.

1. Midas MR18 18-Input Digital Mixer

The Midas MR18 is a powerful and compact 18-input digital mixer designed for both studio and live applications. Controlled via iPad or Android tablets, it offers 16 Midas PRO microphone preamps, ensuring professional-grade sound quality with remarkable warmth and depth. One of its standout features is the built-in tri-mode WiFi router, eliminating the need for external networking equipment and allowing seamless wireless control. The 18 x 18 channel USB 2.0 interface enables easy recording and playback, making it an excellent choice for musicians and sound engineers. Additionally, Dugan-style auto-mixing helps manage microphone gain sharing automatically, reducing feedback and improving clarity in multi-microphone setups. With its rack-mountable design, ULTRANET compatibility for personal monitoring, and versatile effects processing, the MR18 is a highly flexible solution for modern mixing needs.

While the Midas MR18 excels in portability and wireless control, it does come with some drawbacks. The reliance on tablet-based control may not appeal to users who prefer physical faders, and the built-in WiFi can sometimes be unstable in crowded environments. Despite offering professional preamps, the lack of onboard XLR inputs for all channels may be a limitation for some users. Additionally, USB 2.0 connectivity, though functional, is not as fast as more modern standards like USB 3.0 or Thunderbolt. Finally, while firmware updates and remote apps enhance functionality, learning the software and interface can be challenging for beginners.

Key Features, Pros, and Cons

Key Features

• 18-input digital mixer controlled via iPad/Android tablets
• 16 Midas PRO microphone preamps for premium sound quality
• Built-in tri-mode WiFi router for direct operation without external networking
• 18 x 18 USB 2.0 bidirectional interface for multi-track recording
• Dugan-style auto-mixing to automatically manage microphone gain

Pros

• High-quality Midas preamps deliver exceptional sound clarity
• Wireless control allows for flexible mixing from anywhere in the venue
• Comprehensive effects processing with onboard M32 FX engines
• Compact and rack-mountable design, ideal for live and studio use
• Free software updates and app compatibility for various platforms

Cons

• Tablet-based control may not suit those preferring physical faders

2. Behringer XAir XR18 Digital Mixer

The Behringer XAir XR18 is a versatile 18-channel digital mixer controlled via iPad or Android tablets, ideal for both live performances and studio recordings. It boasts 16 Midas-designed mic preamps, offering audiophile-grade sound quality. The built-in tri-mode WiFi router provides direct wireless control, eliminating the need for external routers, while the 18 x 18 bidirectional USB interface allows seamless recording to devices like iPads and PCs. The Dugan-style auto-mixing feature is a standout, automatically adjusting microphone gain levels during live events, especially in multi-microphone settings. This feature, combined with the inclusion of 4 onboard X32 effects engines, makes the XR18 a powerful tool for both sound engineers and musicians. Additionally, the high-resolution 100-band RTA and ULTRANET connectivity for personal monitoring provide exceptional control over both live and studio setups.

However, the XR18 isn’t without its drawbacks. Some users report unstable WiFi connectivity, with issues such as frequent disconnections and latency, which can disrupt live performances. The tablet-only control might not be ideal for all users, particularly those who prefer tactile control with physical faders. Despite the powerful effects engines, the mixer’s reliance on external apps for full functionality can feel limiting, especially for those who want an all-in-one hardware solution. Additionally, MIDI integration and the app’s learning curve can pose challenges for beginners. Finally, while the sound quality is top-notch, the user interface for the app may feel somewhat complex to navigate initially, requiring a bit of time to fully master.

Key Features, Pros, and Cons

Key Features

• 16 Midas-designed mic preamps for superior sound quality
• Built-in tri-mode WiFi router for wireless operation
• 18 x 18 bidirectional USB interface for direct recording
• Dugan-style auto-mixing for automatic microphone gain sharing
• 4 onboard X32 effects engines for professional-grade effects

Pros

• Audiophile-quality sound with Midas preamps
• Wireless control allows flexibility during live events
• Comprehensive effects processing without additional hardware
• High-resolution RTA for precise audio monitoring
• Personal monitoring with ULTRANET connectivity

Cons

• Tablet-only control may not suit users preferring physical controls

Midas MR18 vs Behringer XR18: A Detailed Comparison

The Midas MR18 and Behringer XR18 are both 18-channel digital mixers designed for iPad and Android tablet control, catering to musicians, sound engineers, and live performers. While both products share some similarities in their functionality, they offer distinct features and capabilities that can influence your decision depending on your specific needs.

1. Sound Quality and Preamp Performance

Midas MR18: The Midas MR18 is equipped with 16 award-winning Midas PRO preamps that provide professional-grade sound quality. These preamps are highly regarded in the audio industry for their warmth, depth, and spatial positioning. The MR18 uses the same preamps found in Midas’ top-of-the-line consoles, offering an exceptional level of clarity and sound reproduction.

Behringer XR18: Similarly, the Behringer XR18 features 16 Midas-designed programmable mic preamps, ensuring excellent sound quality. While the preamps are designed by Midas, they may not offer the exact same level of prestige and refinement as the Midas PRO preamps in the MR18. However, they still provide clean, detailed audio, making the XR18 suitable for both live and studio applications.

Conclusion: While both mixers offer superb sound quality, the MR18’s Midas PRO preamps are generally considered superior, offering a more premium sound.

2. Connectivity and Wireless Control

Midas MR18: The MR18 comes with a built-in tri-mode Wi-Fi router, allowing direct wireless control of the mixer without the need for an external router. It offers 18 x 18 bidirectional USB for direct recording, making it a versatile choice for live performances and studio recording alike. The Wi-Fi router also allows performers to control their own monitor mixes via tablets, providing flexibility in live situations.

Behringer XR18: The XR18 also features a built-in tri-mode Wi-Fi router for wireless control, enabling performers and engineers to move freely around the venue while adjusting the mix. The 18 x 18 bidirectional USB interface allows for easy recording to devices like iPads and PCs. The XR18’s Wi-Fi connectivity is also robust, but some users report occasional latency and disconnections, especially in environments with heavy wireless traffic.

Conclusion: Both mixers offer similar wireless functionality, but the Midas MR18 tends to have more stable Wi-Fi in practice, making it a more reliable option for high-pressure live events.

3. Features and Auto-Mixing Technology

Midas MR18: The MR18 offers a revolutionary Dugan-style auto-mixing, which automatically manages microphone gain sharing in real-time, reducing feedback and noise issues, especially in multi-microphone setups. This feature is essential for live events like panel discussions or conferences, where multiple microphones are used simultaneously. The MR18 also comes with 4 digital effects engines that provide high-quality delay, chorus, dynamics, and reverb effects.

Behringer XR18: The Behringer XR18 incorporates X AIR Gain Sharing technology, which works similarly to the Dugan-style auto-mixing system in the MR18. It automatically controls microphone levels without the need for manual adjustments, which helps maintain a consistent audio level across various speakers. Additionally, the XR18 offers 4 X32 onboard effects engines, providing professional-grade reverb, delay, and EQ, all without the need for external hardware.

Conclusion: Both mixers feature auto-mixing technology and high-quality onboard effects, but the MR18’s Dugan-style auto-mixing is considered more advanced and may offer better performance in more demanding multi-mic environments.

4. Ease of Use and Control

Midas MR18: The MR18 is controlled entirely via a tablet, using the M AIR Mix app for iOS, Android, and other platforms. The app interface is user-friendly, providing access to all the mixer’s functions, including effects, EQ, and routing. However, it may take some time for new users to fully grasp all the features, especially for those unfamiliar with digital mixers.

Behringer XR18: The XR18 also uses tablet-based control, with its own X AIR app available for both iOS and Android. The app allows for comprehensive control over the mix, and like the MR18, users can remotely control monitors and adjust the main mix from anywhere in the venue. Some users report that the XR18’s app is slightly more intuitive and easier to use for beginners, though both mixers have robust features.

Conclusion: Both mixers are tablet-controlled, but the XR18’s app may be slightly easier for beginners to navigate, making it a better choice for those new to digital mixing.

5. Price and Value for Money

Midas MR18: The MR18 is priced higher than the XR18, reflecting its premium build quality, superior Midas PRO preamps, and advanced features like the Dugan-style auto-mixing. It’s ideal for professionals who demand the highest sound quality and advanced mixing capabilities.

Behringer XR18: The XR18 is a more budget-friendly option, providing many of the same features as the MR18 but at a lower price point. The Midas-designed preamps still offer great sound quality, making the XR18 an excellent choice for those who need a reliable mixer without breaking the bank.

Conclusion: The XR18 offers excellent value for money, making it a great choice for those on a budget or for smaller events. However, for those who prioritize top-tier audio quality and advanced features, the MR18 justifies its higher price.

Comparison Table

Feature	Midas MR18	Behringer XR18
Sound Quality	16 Midas PRO preamps for superior audio	16 Midas-designed preamps
Wireless Control	Built-in tri-mode Wi-Fi router	Built-in tri-mode Wi-Fi router
USB Interface	18 x 18 bidirectional USB	18 x 18 bidirectional USB
Auto-Mixing Technology	Dugan-style auto-mixing	X AIR Gain Sharing
Effects Engines	4 M32 effects engines	4 X32 onboard effects engines
App Control	M AIR Mix app (iOS/Android)	X AIR app (iOS/Android)
Price	Higher-end pricing	More affordable

FAQ

1. What is the difference between the Midas MR18 and Behringer XR18 in terms of sound quality?

The main difference between the Midas MR18 and Behringer XR18 lies in the preamp design. The MR18 features 16 Midas PRO preamps, which are considered some of the best in the industry for delivering exceptional sound clarity, warmth, and depth. These preamps are renowned for their quality and are used in some of Midas’ most prestigious consoles. On the other hand, the Behringer XR18 uses Midas-designed preamps that deliver excellent sound quality, but they may not be on the same level as the PRO preamps found in the MR18. While both mixers provide impressive audio, the MR18 tends to offer a slightly higher level of sound fidelity due to the advanced design of its preamps.

2. How does the auto-mixing feature work in these mixers?

Both the Midas MR18 and Behringer XR18 come equipped with advanced auto-mixing technologies, but they differ in implementation. The MR18 uses Dugan-style auto-mixing, which is a sophisticated system that automatically adjusts microphone gain sharing during events with multiple microphones, such as panel discussions or press conferences. This system ensures that the mix remains clear and balanced without unwanted feedback or noise. The XR18, on the other hand, uses X AIR Gain Sharing, a similar feature that automates microphone levels in real-time, helping maintain a consistent audio level when multiple speakers are active. Both systems are designed to handle large, complex audio setups with ease, but the MR18’s Dugan-style auto-mixing is widely regarded as more advanced and suited for demanding live environments.

3. Can I control both mixers wirelessly?

Yes, both the Midas MR18 and Behringer XR18 allow wireless control via built-in Wi-Fi routers, enabling you to control your mix remotely from a tablet. The MR18 provides a tri-mode Wi-Fi router, allowing you to connect directly without needing an external router. This router also enables control from multiple devices simultaneously, giving performers the ability to control their monitor mixes via their own tablets. Similarly, the XR18 also has a tri-mode Wi-Fi router for direct wireless control, but some users report occasional latency and disconnections, especially in crowded wireless environments. Both mixers offer flexibility, but the MR18’s Wi-Fi connectivity tends to be more stable in demanding live situations.

4. What kind of applications are these mixers suitable for?

Both the Midas MR18 and Behringer XR18 are designed for a variety of applications, making them versatile choices for different audio setups. They are ideal for live performances, studio recordings, and event audio. The MR18, with its superior preamps and advanced auto-mixing technology, is perfect for professional-level live sound mixing, including complex events such as conferences or performances with multiple microphones. The XR18 is also suitable for live sound but offers a more budget-friendly solution for small to medium-sized events. Additionally, both mixers are capable of recording directly to devices like iPads or PCs, making them great for mobile recording or studio sessions. Whether you’re a live sound engineer, musician, or content creator, both mixers provide the tools necessary for high-quality sound management.

5. Are there any software or app compatibility differences?

Both mixers support app-based control, but there are slight differences in terms of compatibility and user experience. The Midas MR18 uses the M AIR Mix app for iOS, Android, and other platforms, allowing full control of the mixer’s functions. While the app is robust and feature-rich, it may take a bit of time for new users to fully master all its features. The Behringer XR18, on the other hand, uses the X AIR app, which is also available for iOS and Android devices. The XR18 app is often considered more intuitive and easier to use for beginners, though both apps provide comprehensive control over the mixer’s features. Both apps are free to download and offer remote control, making these mixers extremely flexible for live performances and studio use.

Conclusion

Both the Midas MR18 and Behringer XR18 are excellent choices for live sound engineers and musicians, offering top-tier performance and flexibility. The MR18 stands out for its superior sound quality and advanced features like Dugan-style auto-mixing, while the XR18 offers great value for money with Midas-designed preamps and user-friendly app control. Your choice will depend on your budget and whether you need the extra capabilities and premium sound quality that the MR18 provides, or if the more affordable and equally capable XR18 meets your needs.