BISSELL Big Green vs Rug Doctor Pro Carpet Cleaner: A Comparison

When it comes to deep cleaning carpets, two brands often come up in discussions: BISSELL and Rug Doctor. Both offer powerful carpet cleaners designed to tackle deep dirt, stains, and even pet messes. However, deciding which one to invest in can be tricky, especially when considering the differences in performance, ease of use, and specialized features. In this report, we’ll compare the BISSELL Big Green Carpet Cleaner and the Rug Doctor Pro Carpet Cleaner, focusing on their unique features, pros, cons, and the needs they best address.

BISSELL Big Green Carpet Cleaner

The BISSELL® Big Green® Professional Carpet Cleaner is a powerful and efficient solution for deep cleaning carpets. With its 1.75-gallon tank capacity and 12-amp power rating, this cleaner delivers excellent performance, removing dirt and tough stains with ease. Its rotating DirtLifter PowerBrush provides a thorough clean, and it cleans both on the forward and backward pass, which significantly reduces cleaning time. The inclusion of the BISSELL PRO MAX Formula with Stain Protect Technology ensures long-lasting results, leaving carpets looking fresh and new. Customers have reported that the machine is capable of cleaning large rooms in one go, and the cleaning results are impressive, with carpets drying quickly after use.

However, despite its impressive performance, the BISSELL Big Green Carpet Cleaner does have some downsides. It is quite heavy, weighing in at 42 pounds, which can make it challenging to maneuver, especially for individuals who are not accustomed to handling bulky equipment. Additionally, its large size may make storage more difficult. While the cleaner is effective for deep cleaning, it does require frequent tank changes, and although it reduces cleaning time, it might not be the most suitable choice for those seeking a lightweight option.

Key Features, Pros, and Cons

Key Features:

1. 1.75-gallon tank capacity for fewer trips to the sink.
2. Rotating DirtLifter PowerBrush for deep-down dirt removal.
3. Cleans on both forward and backward passes.
4. Includes BISSELL PRO MAX Formula with Stain Protect Technology.
5. Comes with a 9-inch Long Reach Hose and 6-inch Tough Stain Tool.

Pros:

1. Effectively removes dirt and tough stains.
2. Reduces cleaning time with forward and backward cleaning action.
3. Large water tanks reduce the frequency of refills.
4. Powerful and long-lasting build quality.
5. Fast drying time for carpets after cleaning.

Cons:

1. Takes up significant storage space.

Rug Doctor Pro Carpet Cleaner

The Rug Doctor Pro Deep Commercial Carpet Cleaning Machine, especially in the Pet Bundle version, is a high-powered option designed for both home and commercial use. It delivers superior cleaning performance with best-in-class suction power, making it highly effective at removing dirt, grime, and pet stains. The machine is equipped with large 1.5-gallon tanks, which reduce the frequency of refills and make cleaning large areas more efficient. The intuitive back-and-forth cleaning motion, much like a vacuum, ensures ease of use, and the digital indicator lights provide clear guidance on when to refill the tank or check the brush roll. The adjustable handle makes it comfortable for users of different heights, and the Pet Bundle includes both a Pro Pet Cleaning Solution and a Pro Urine Eliminator Spray, adding value to the product.

However, the Rug Doctor Pro Deep Machine does have some drawbacks. While many users find it effective, there have been complaints about the machine’s durability. Some customers reported that the pump stopped working or the machine broke after only one use, suggesting potential quality control issues. The spray system also seems to malfunction, as some users found that it doesn’t dispense water properly. Additionally, the machine’s weight—at 32.5 pounds—makes it less convenient for prolonged use, and its condition upon arrival has been a concern for some, with reports of receiving used or damaged units.

Key Features, Pros, and Cons

Key Features:

1. Best-in-class suction power for deep cleaning.
2. Large 1.5-gallon tanks for fewer refills.
3. Digital indicator lights for easy operation.
4. Adjustable handle for ergonomic comfort.
5. Includes 48 oz. Pro Pet Cleaning Solution and 22 oz. Urine Eliminator Spray.

Pros:

1. Powerful suction removes dirt and stains effectively.
2. Large tanks minimize interruptions for refills.
3. Easy to use with a vacuum-like cleaning motion.
4. Versatile with both home and commercial applications.
5. Pet Bundle adds value with specialized cleaning solutions.

Cons:

1. Durability issues, with reports of the pump failing or breaking after minimal use.

Comparison of BISSELL Big Green and Rug Doctor Pro Carpet Cleaner

When it comes to choosing a carpet cleaner, the BISSELL® Big Green® Professional Carpet Cleaner and the Rug Doctor Pro Deep Commercial Carpet Cleaning Machine are two of the most popular options available. Both are designed for powerful cleaning, targeting deep dirt, stains, and grime, but they each offer distinct features that make them suitable for different needs.

Performance and Cleaning Efficiency

The BISSELL® Big Green® Professional Carpet Cleaner offers excellent cleaning results with its 12-amp power rating and 1.75-gallon tank. The rotating DirtLifter PowerBrush and forward-and-backward cleaning action help remove deep-down dirt and stains more effectively than many competing models. This cleaner is known for its ability to clean large areas with fewer tank changes, making it ideal for bigger spaces. It also boasts a relatively quick drying time, which is essential for homeowners who want to walk on their carpets sooner.

In contrast, the Rug Doctor Pro Deep features commercial-grade suction power, making it one of the most powerful carpet cleaners available. It is equipped with large 1.5-gallon tanks and a high-capacity motor, which help in pulling out dirt and grime more efficiently. The Pro Deep’s easy-to-use back-and-forth cleaning motion and large tanks reduce refilling time, making it a great choice for large spaces or frequent cleaning. However, some users have reported occasional issues with the spray dispenser and the durability of the pump.

Feature	BISSELL Big Green	Rug Doctor Pro Deep
Power Rating	12 amps	Commercial-grade suction power
Tank Capacity	1.75 gallons	1.5 gallons
Cleaning Method	Forward and backward pass	Back-and-forth pass
Drying Time	Quick drying	Moderate drying time
Durability	High quality but reports of occasional issues	Mixed durability reviews; some users report failures

Ease of Use and Handling

The BISSELL Big Green is known for its user-friendly design. The forward-and-backward cleaning motion is easy to control, and it’s equipped with a large 1.75-gallon tank, reducing the need for constant refills. However, it is quite heavy, weighing 42 pounds, which may be cumbersome for some users, particularly during extended cleaning sessions. The adjustable handle makes it easier to find a comfortable grip, but its size may make it less convenient to store.

On the other hand, the Rug Doctor Pro Deep is slightly lighter at 32.5 pounds, which makes it easier to maneuver compared to the BISSELL model. It features digital indicator lights that alert users when it’s time to refill the cleaning solution or when the brush roll isn’t functioning properly. Additionally, the adjustable handle allows users to adjust it for better comfort during use. However, its weight can still pose a challenge during prolonged usage, especially for those who need to carry the machine up and down stairs or across multiple rooms.

Key Features and Versatility

The BISSELL Big Green shines in its comprehensive design. It comes with an XL DirtLifter PowerBrush, a 9-inch long reach hose, and a 6-inch tough stain tool for deep cleaning hard-to-reach areas. The included BISSELL PRO MAX formula with Stain Protect Technology helps tackle stubborn stains effectively. The machine also cleans both forward and backward, cutting down on cleaning time.

The Rug Doctor Pro Deep, especially with its Pet Bundle, is ideal for households with pets. It includes a 48-ounce Pro Pet Cleaning Solution and a 22-ounce Pro Urine Eliminator Spray, making it a great option for removing pet stains and odors. The large 1.5-gallon tanks allow for long cleaning sessions, and the commercial-grade motor ensures powerful suction. The motorized upholstery tool is also sold separately, adding versatility for cleaning furniture, pet beds, and car interiors.

Feature	BISSELL Big Green	Rug Doctor Pro Deep
Cleaning Tool	XL DirtLifter PowerBrush, 9-inch hose, 6-inch stain tool	Pro Pet Cleaning Solution, Urine Eliminator Spray
Included Formula	BISSELL PRO MAX Formula with Stain Protect Technology	Pro Pet Cleaning Solution (48 oz), Urine Eliminator Spray (22 oz)
Versatility	Suitable for deep carpet cleaning, stairs, and tough stains	Includes solutions for pet stains, upholstery, car interiors, and more
Motorized Upholstery Tool	No	Yes (sold separately)

Durability and Maintenance

The BISSELL Big Green is praised for its durability, with many users reporting long-term reliability. The construction is solid, and while it is built to withstand heavy use, the machine’s weight may cause strain during handling. However, occasional complaints about the machine becoming faulty after multiple uses have been reported.

The Rug Doctor Pro Deep, on the other hand, has mixed reviews regarding durability. Some users have had no issues and find it to be a long-lasting investment. However, there are consistent reports of malfunctioning pumps and spray dispensers, which can be frustrating. Additionally, the machine has been noted for occasional issues with the brush roll and general wear-and-tear after several uses.

FAQ

What makes the BISSELL Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner unique?

The BISSELL Big Green is known for its powerful performance with its 12-amp motor and DirtLifter PowerBrush. It cleans both forward and backward, which helps reduce cleaning time, making it an excellent option for large spaces. Its large 1.75-gallon tank capacity and quick-drying ability make it ideal for high-traffic areas where you need carpets to dry fast. Additionally, it includes the BISSELL PRO MAX Formula with Stain Protect Technology, which ensures a deep clean and helps protect your carpet from future stains.

How does the Rug Doctor Pro Deep Carpet Cleaner perform with pet stains?

The Rug Doctor Pro Deep is specifically designed with pet owners in mind, especially when paired with the Pet Bundle. It includes Pro Pet Carpet Cleaning Solution and Urine Eliminator Spray, making it very effective at removing pet stains and odors. The powerful suction removes dirt deep within the fibers of the carpet, and the included solutions work to break down and neutralize urine stains, which is a common concern for pet owners.

Which cleaner is easier to use: BISSELL Big Green or Rug Doctor Pro Deep?

The BISSELL Big Green is very user-friendly, with a forward-and-backward cleaning action that mimics vacuuming, making it easy to operate. Its large water tank minimizes the need for frequent refills. However, it is on the heavier side, weighing 42 pounds, which may make it challenging to maneuver during prolonged cleaning sessions. The Rug Doctor Pro Deep is also easy to use, with a back-and-forth cleaning motion and digital indicator lights that guide users through the cleaning process. While slightly lighter at 32.5 pounds, it still requires a bit of effort to move around, especially when cleaning large areas.

Are both carpet cleaners durable?

Both the BISSELL Big Green and the Rug Doctor Pro Deep are built to be durable, but they have different durability experiences. The BISSELL Big Green is often praised for its solid construction and long-lasting reliability. However, some users have reported issues with the machine breaking down or malfunctioning after extended use. The Rug Doctor Pro Deep also has a reputation for reliability but has received mixed reviews regarding durability, with some customers reporting that the pump or spray dispenser malfunctions after a few uses.

Which carpet cleaner is better for large spaces?

If you have a large area to clean, the BISSELL Big Green may be the better choice due to its 1.75-gallon tank and powerful DirtLifter PowerBrush. The large tank allows you to clean more area before needing to refill, and the forward-and-backward cleaning feature reduces your overall cleaning time. The Rug Doctor Pro Deep is also effective for large spaces, but with a 1.5-gallon tank, you may need to refill more often. However, it offers strong suction power and versatility for a variety of cleaning tasks.

Conclusion

Both the BISSELL Big Green and the Rug Doctor Pro Deep are excellent choices for deep carpet cleaning, but they cater to slightly different needs. The BISSELL Big Green excels in efficiency, with its large tank capacity, quick drying time, and powerful DirtLifter PowerBrush. It is a great option for large spaces and those looking for a reliable, easy-to-use machine. However, its weight and bulkiness may be a concern for some.

The Rug Doctor Pro Deep offers impressive suction power and versatility, especially for pet owners, thanks to its specialized cleaning solutions. It is slightly lighter than the BISSELL and offers an adjustable handle for comfort. However, its durability and spray dispenser issues can detract from its overall appeal.

For users seeking an all-around powerful, reliable cleaner with a focus on pet stains, the Rug Doctor Pro Deep might be the better option. However, for those who prioritize ease of use and quick drying time, the BISSELL Big Green could be the more suitable choice.